A Response to Melissa D’Angelo on Islam, Religious Freedom, and Western Civilization
I recently read an article written by Melissa D’Angelo concerning Muslims living in America, religious freedom, and the fears that some Americans have expressed about the growing influence of Islam in Western society.
I have no reason to question the sincerity of this writer or the pleasant experiences she describes growing up among Muslim neighbors in Michigan. I am thankful that she has enjoyed friendships with people of different religious and cultural backgrounds. I, too, have Muslim friends whom I respect and genuinely love.
However, I believe her article presents a very incomplete picture of Islam, particularly its history, its influence in certain parts of the world, and the suffering that many people have endured under governments and movements committed to radical interpretations of Islamic teaching.
My concerns are not based upon ignorance of Muslims or a lack of personal contact with them. I have spent considerable time ministering among Muslims in India, traveled extensively throughout Europe, and developed friendships with Muslims from several countries. I have also studied the Quran, the Hadith, and the life of Muhammad.
These experiences have given me reasons to be deeply concerned about certain teachings and political expressions of Islam, particularly where they conflict with religious liberty, freedom of conscience, and the fundamental principles upon which Western civilization has been built.
I believe Christians are commanded by our Lord Jesus Christ to love all people, including those whose religious convictions differ radically from our own. We must treat them with kindness, dignity, and respect. But Christian love does not require us to abandon our convictions, ignore historical realities, or remain silent concerning religious persecution and injustice.
It is in that spirit that I would like to respond to several statements made in this article.
She says she “laughs at some of these comments about Muslims being elected to office and the fear that somehow America is going to turn Muslim.”
Her laughter is the mockery of an uneducated opinion. People in Europe, where thousands of young women have been raped by Muslim gangs, are not laughing at the presence of those who have come to the West but have no intention of respecting our laws or our freedoms.
I do not have the time to list all of the outrageous crimes committed against ordinary citizens, both here in the United States and around the world.
Millions of people in Iran are not laughing at the vicious persecution they endure at the hands of radical Muslim leaders who have terrorized that nation and killed thousands of people through torture and execution. Did you know that the vast majority of Iranians are not Muslim and desperately want their country freed from Islamic tyranny?
People in Africa are not laughing at the persecution Christians are facing, with their churches being burned and their children being raped and murdered.
People all over Europe are not laughing at the fact that their towns and villages have been taken over by Muslim gangs, where their wives and children are no longer safe and many are forced to move away for safety.
I have spent a good part of my life in Europe and have witnessed the demise of the West firsthand.
This writer may find it charming to hear Islamic calls to prayer in the morning. But those who are suffering at the hands of radical Muslims do not find any of this amusing.
Our Savior, the Lord Jesus, has commissioned His Church to preach the Gospel, defend the faith, and proclaim the truth to all the world. While every Christian is called by the Lord to love all people and to be at peace with all people, if possible, they are still called to speak the truth in love to those who follow false religions.
I have spent a year of my life ministering to Muslims in India. I have seen firsthand the tragedies of Christians persecuted by the followers of Muhammad. Churches have been burned, and pastors have been beaten and stoned. These dear people are not laughing at all.
I have Iranian friends who are not laughing, having had relatives and friends killed and tortured by the Islamic regime in Iran.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali, a refugee from Somalia, is not laughing at the terrible things she endured that forced her to flee a Muslim country for safety. Brigitte Gabriel is a Lebanese-American Christian author, speaker, and outspoken critic of radical Islam. Brigitte is not laughing.
This writer has a short memory of how Muslim terrorists flew planes into buildings in New York. She writes: “I have to laugh at some of these comments about Muslims being elected to office and the fear that somehow America is going to turn Muslim.”
She continues: “I grew up right next to Dearborn, Michigan, home to one of the largest Arab American communities in the country. I lived in Hamtramck, where hearing the call to prayer was part of everyday life. I grew up surrounded by different religions, cultures, languages, traditions, and beliefs. And you know what? It was a beautiful thing.”
We are certainly enriched in this country by the many different traditions and customs that our friends from other lands have brought to us.
But we are not amused at the attempts of some of these people who have ties to radical organizations that have stated publicly that they intend to make the nations of the West Islamic states. I have traveled to England four or five times a year for over twenty years. I have had young Muslim men tell me straight to my face that their goal is to turn England into an Islamic state. If this writer had any concept of what is taking place all over Europe right now she would have not been able to say some of the things she said.
I have seen with my own eyes that there are communities that have been completely taken over by Muslims. Entire parts of the country are now almost unrecognizable as parts of England.
People over there are not laughing.
This writer said, "Nobody tried to convert me. Nobody forced me to cover my hair. Nobody took away my freedom.”
Good for her. But her experience, as limited as it has been, is hardly a testimony to the goodwill and wishes of the many millions of militant Muslims who aggressively persecute and seek to convert people to their false religion.
Does it bother anyone that I say Islam is a false religion? Why should that bother you? If you are a true Christian, then indeed you understand that Islam is not the true religion, no matter what its followers may say.
I have been respectful to my Muslim friends and approach these discussions with them with kindness, respect, and Christian love. But remember, Muslims have no scruples about saying that my Savior is not the Son of God and that He did not die on the cross for our sins. They have no hesitation about saying that non-Muslims are infidels. If this writer is not aware of the fact that Islam is aggressively proselytizing all over the world, she is able to write the kind of things that she has presented.
This writer continues and says, "In fact, I’ve experienced more people trying to push their Christian beliefs on me than I ever experienced from my Muslim neighbors.” Yes, it always comes down to this: those who defend Islam must include this put-down about Christians trying to convert them or trying to share their faith with them.
If the Bible is true, if there is a Heaven and a Hell, and if Jesus really is the Son of God, then Christians are commanded by their Lord to share their faith.
I cannot speak for anyone who may be sharing their faith in ways that are rude or unkind, but as a Christian minister, I can tell you that every true follower of Jesus will give an account of how faithful they were in sharing the story of Calvary’s love with their friends and neighbors.
The message of Jesus is so wonderful, so filled with grace and truth, that we can truly say it is the greatest story the world has ever heard.
This writer continues and says something incredible: “And can we talk about the obsession with Muslim women covering their hair? I was raised Catholic. Have you seen a nun? (By the way Catholic nuns are a small group of devoted women who voluntarily choose to dress the way they do. This is hardly a comparable position). Women have covered their hair and bodies as an expression of religious devotion across cultures and faiths for centuries. Why is one woman’s religious devotion respected while another’s is feared?”
I am shocked that she, as a woman, finds it acceptable that this religion requires and many times forces its women to be covered in the manner that some are.
The picture displayed hardly captures the reality of what millions of Muslim women endure. In Islamic countries, many women are covered from head to foot. Here are the different distinctions:
1. Burqa — Covers the entire body from head to foot, including the face and eyes. A mesh screen allows the woman to see. It is particularly associated with Afghanistan.
2. Niqab — Covers the face, leaving only the eyes visible. It is often worn with a loose garment covering the body.
3. Hijab — A headscarf covering the hair, neck, and sometimes shoulders, but leaving the face visible.
4. Chador — A full-body cloak commonly worn in Iran. It covers the hair and body but generally leaves the face exposed.
Have you ever asked a Muslim why they require their women to dress like this? I have been told by Muslim friends and by those who have lived in Islamic countries that this covering was necessary to prevent men from lusting after their women.
Does this writer take this into account? How would she feel if she were told she must dress like this? And has this writer ever read the Quran to understand the views that Islam has about women? It’s very disturbing.
Has she ever read about genital mutilation of Muslim women or honor killings that frequently take place?
What a charming religion!
Or has she read of the violent history of Islam’s expansion as it exploded out of the desert in the seventh century, beginning a centuries-long campaign of terror and murder, subjugating vast areas of the earth to Islam? Islam means “submission."
Is she aware that the Ottoman Empire conquered many Christian nations and forced Christians to turn their best sons over to the conquerors to be trained as Janissaries to help fight in jihads for Islam? I could go on and on about what she has written.
I would tell you that if you think I am just a conservative ideologue, tune in to liberal Bill Maher and see what he has to say about this “culturally rich” religion.
Finally, she says, "Muslims are not some mysterious group of people coming to take over America.” Is she certain about that? In fact, there have been many cases already in our country as well as all across Europe where Muslims are imposing Sharia law on towns, villages, and communities where they have grown in number and in power.
How can she be so uninformed that thousands of Muslims have already been deported all over the world for planning terror attacks, insurrections, and instigating violence?
Both my wife and I have had Muslims tell us to our faces that they are planning on turning the West into Islamic states. My wife was traveling back to Flint, Michigan, and was seated next to a well-known Muslim speaker who was flying into Michigan to speak at Baker College in Flint. He openly stated that Muslims were using our laws in order to accomplish their goals of imposing sharia law and Islam upon us. There was nothing subtle about this.
I know that not every Muslim is a terrorist or radical. But I have had enough exposure to Islam to know that it is a dangerous religion. The religion of peace has had a very bloody history. We need to distinguish between several things:
- Islam: The religion and its theological teachings.
- Islamism: Political movements seeking to organize government and society according to particular interpretations of Islamic principles.
- Violent Islamist extremism: Movements employing terrorism, coercion, or violence to advance their objectives.
- Individual Muslims: People whose religious convictions and attitudes toward democracy, religious freedom, and other faiths vary considerably.
While not every Muslim is a terrorist, there are millions who either are or sympathetic to extremist groups. In many communities where there were large numbers of Muslims, when 9/11 took place, there were large gatherings of people who were celebrating those violent actions of terrorism.
I know what I have written will upset some of my friends. I have not responded many times when people write their opinions about things. I respectfully disagree with this woman who has written this post. I think she is sincere, but I believe she is very uninformed and naive about what she is saying.
I have read the Quran and the Hadith and studied the biography of Muhammad. These three sources of information are considered reliable sources of information about this religion. I have Muslim friends. I have Muslim doctors. I have Muslims who come to my house for various activities. I have a genuine love for them all, but I am not blind to the dangers of this religion.
We should be more careful about what we say and think.
